The verdict in Johnson's case would set a precedent for tens of thousands of other people who had also filed cases against Monsanto. For this man to travel across the country to be at this event speaks to the incredible individual he is, andDewayne Johnson is an unquestioned hero to those of us in the organic community. Hes looking for answers, a Monsanto product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, the companys medical sciences and outreach executive. When the doctor said I had cancer, my wife was sitting there with me. I just say the big company. I dont want to be slanderous. . Christopher Loder, a spokesman for Bayer, said the company was disappointed and would consider seeking further judicial review. Why zippo ion the false hoods in her preivious work? His job included spraying Monsantos Ranger Pro from 50-gallon drums 20 to 30 times a year for two to three hours a day. Updated on Nov 14, 2019, 10:56 a.m. For more than a decade, Tradin Organic has been working with local partners in The Philippines to bring a diversified range of organic products to the market, such as coconut oil, tropical fruits and even cocoa. On a typical day I would fill up my little container with raw pesticide liquid and then put that in the back of my truck and then mix a load before I would leave the yard. His beat includes state and federal courts in California, the Supreme Court and the State Bar. Its crazy. 54 points to armyprivateoctopus99. It was this event that Johnson alleges caused his cancer. "The main thing that sticks out to me that I remember is that she told us it was safe enough to drink," he recalled. You have permission to edit this article. Why zippo on the real mission of usrtk. Thats something of the past.. The case is Johnson vs. Monsanto, S264158. Superior Court Judge Suzanne Bolanos reduced the punitive award to $39.25 million, citing U.S. Supreme Court limits on such damages, but refused to overturn the verdict. https://www.forbes.com/sites/geoffreykabat/2017/10/23/iarcs-glyphosate-gate-scandal/. [16] The EPA has evaluated the carcinogenic potential of glyphosate multiple times since 1986. Partly cloudy skies this evening will become overcast overnight. Glyphosate, the active ingredient, is the worlds most widely used herbicide. Email: begelko@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @BobEgelko. While slashing Johnsons damage award, which already had been greatly reduced by the trial judge, the court said there was evidence to support the jurys conclusion that Monsanto acted with a conscious disregard for public safety by disregarding evidence that its Roundup herbicide was dangerous and attempting to influence regulatory agencies. But there are only so many things you can buy. His beat includes state and federal courts in California, the Supreme Court and the State Bar. The jury deliberated for three days. hide. Bayer attorneys have made the strategic legal decision not to appeal their initial court loss to DeWayne Lee Johnson and focus their efforts on having the $80 million Edwin Haldeman verdict overturned by the Supreme Court. Glyphosate, the active ingredient, is the worlds most widely used herbicide. I hate to think about dying. One such product that I recently discovered at Whole Foods Tribeca is Sol Simple Solar Dried Bananas. Sign up for your Modern Farmer Weekly Newsletter. He wasn't sure what it was, but it spread and spread. But it won't last long. Award to Vallejo groundskeeper in Monsanto cancer case slashed again verdict upheld, Visiting Stanford researcher from China accused of visa fraud, Trumps threat to send federal forces to Oakland draws California pushback, Track water shortages and restrictions across Bay Area. The father of three shared, "My dad was kicked out of his house at 13 and he was homeless, so that then . My kids are handling it well but they dont dig the attention were a small family and weve just been trying to deal with becoming nationally known. In fact, earlier this year the EPA re-approved glyphosate as a commercially-available pesticide for 15 years. Right To Know (USRTK), a non-profit investigative research group focused on the food industry, Brent Wisner, one of Johnsons trial attorneys, said the reduction in damages was the result of a deep flaw in California tort law., Wisner said, California law does not allow a plaintiff to recover for a shortened life expectancy [and] this effectively rewards a defendant for killing a plaintiff, as opposed to just injuring him. Heres the impact of the latest Yosemite breaks snow record; park closed indefinitely, 2022 tax returns: IRS further extends filing deadline for most Californians, Another winter storm? Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson says he is "full of gratitude" for the love and support he's received in the wake of his father's death. At the end of his second spraying season, Johnson discovered a lesion on his knee. This is a carousel. each comment to let us know of abusive posts. (At the time, he was still playing football competitively with the NFL.) Heres the impact of the latest Yosemite breaks snow record; park closed indefinitely, 2022 tax returns: IRS further extends filing deadline for most Californians, Another winter storm? And it was that jurys 2018 decision to award Johnson $289 million in damages that set the stage for Bayerthe German drugmaker that bought Monsanto that yearto agree to pay nearly $11 billion to settle tens of thousands of similar claims, one of the largest ever settlements in US civil litigation history. But you see in the emails that came out that there was really no concern for me. BARTs second Transbay Tube could get quashed as planners scale back S.F. We also meet Monsanto health execs and others who maintain their product is safe. Lees case was the first, in effect a test case for a mass tort case against Monsanto that had tens of thousands of plaintiffs. The company could argue in federal court that the verdict conflicted with U.S. regulation of pesticides and the EPAs safety findings, an argument the state court rejected. police arrest 2 teens suspected in brutal attack near Dolores Park, People arent getting the COVID booster. A. Its not possible. It is a priority for CBC to create products that are accessible to all in Canada including people with visual, hearing, motor and cognitive challenges. "[The] boys used to sleep on the couch Araceli got up, worked her two jobs, and I did whatever I could, when I could, you know. Im just a regular guy from a small town called Vallejo in the California Bay Area who happened to seek the truth about my failing health and found answers. He claims that their weed-killer was a substantial factor in causing his cancer. Tag: Dewayne "Lee" Johnson Dying man asks California Supreme Court to restore jury award in Monsanto Roundup case Carey Gillam August 31, 2020 Bayer asks appeals court to again cut Roundup damage award owed to California groundskeeper with cancer Carey Gillam August 5, 2020 Bayer Makes Bid for "Trust" Amid Third Monsanto Cancer Trial Carey Gillam His mother . ", In Into the Weeds, Araceli Johnson worries about her family's future. Good grief, Jason must have no journalism training to have written that puff piece. In 1986, glyphosate was initially classified as Group C: "Possible Human Carcinogen", but later recommended as Group D: "Not Classifiable as to Human Carcinogenicity" due to lack of statistical significance in previously examined rat tumor studies. How Old - Age: 50. They have fought science. Monsanto owes Johnson annual interest at the rate of 10 percent from April of 2018 until it pays the final judgment. The celebrity is still alive. save. Carey Gillam is a journalist and author of Whitewash: The Story of a Weed Killer, Cancer and the Corruption of Science. 2. "No one called [Johnson] back. Its exciting sometimes to think that we may get millions of dollars, but right now we know were not. There may be valid policy arguments to support allowing the recovery of damages for a shortened life expectancy, but state law entitled Johnson only to compensation for future harm he was reasonably certain to suffer, Presiding Justice James Humes said in the 3-0 ruling. Dewayne "Lee" Johnson, after all, had already been diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and his prognosis was grim. And it gets worse and worse and worse," said Wisner. pizza favorite shuts down after 13 years, plus more closings, Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). The court then reduced the punitive damages to an equal amount. Ive seen reports that I want an apology but thats not true. The Bay Area will catch a break from winter storms for a couple days, but it wont last very long. They found, unanimously, that Monsanto had failed to warn Johnson and other consumers of the cancer risks posed by its glyphosate-based products. He claimed that Ranger Pro, another of the company's glyphosate-based herbicides, was a substantial contributing factor in causing his non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Tradin Organic is improving the lives of farmers in Ethiopia with its regenerative organic avocado project. Johnson now near death according to his doctors sued Monsanto in June, testifying that the herbicide likely caused his cancer. Into the Weeds: Dewayne Lee Johnson vs. Monsanto Companyis a cautionary environmental story, that raises unsettling questions about whats in the food we eat, and how our farming practices are affecting the biosphere. When search suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. In August, jurors unanimously agreed and awarded him a total of. So that people who are turned off by pesticides and glyphosatethe idea of, you know, having to read a very science-y bookwould be drawn into one mans story of suffering from cancer., , Gillam says, was how the companies on which she was reporting treated her. Still, the appeals court said that Monsantos argument that the dearth of scientific findings about glyphosate was not supported. The trial was the first in the nation among thousands of lawsuits against Monsanto by cancer victims who had used Roundup or a more concentrated version of the product called Ranger Pro. Bay Area gets a break from winter storm. Apparently, its some new melanoma. While Monsanto built a step-by-step action plan to undermine her credibility and reportinga strategy detailed in. "I will call him," he said. In August, 2018, Johnson was awarded $289 million by a unanimous jury. After his symptoms appeared, he said he twice called Monsanto to ask if the product was dangerous, and was promised a return call but never got one. He is still alive. Is Californias drought finally over? ", "He'd been unemployed for so long," says Johnson's mother, DeLois Harvey. Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson has strong ties to both his parents, who raised him between the U.S. and New Zealand. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. And I want to do more with my music and art. pizza favorite shuts down after 13 years, plus more closings, Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). Gillam obtained after her first book was publishedshe believes Bayer kept things above board by comparison. I had a good job. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Baichwal lets us get to know him and some of the people in his life. It was almost in foreclosure so we were able to rent it for a good price. Employers can change that. The epic California snowpack is inching toward record levels. They sent me to UCSF (University of California San Francisco) and then to Stanford. 54 points to armyprivateoctopus99. A bunch of doctors came and checked me out. Roundup cancer case appeals by plaintiff and defendant turned down by Calif. Supreme Court, Award to Vallejo groundskeeper in Monsanto cancer case slashed again verdict upheld, Monsanto cancer case pits federal product label against California law, Track water shortages and restrictions across Bay Area. At the time of the trial in 2018, Johnson, 46, was severely ill with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, with lesions covering his body, and his doctors said he had two years to live. person will not be tolerated. could be eligible for a share of $104 million. Jurors had awarded Johnson $33 million for the lost years of his life $1 million for each year of his normal life expectancy but the appellate panel said California law does not authorize such damages, and reduced that sum to $4 million for two years of pain and suffering. Goldstein replied that the story is not making any sense to me at all, and said he would call Johnson back. Johnson, however, is still very much alive todaysix and a half years and counting since he was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma and two-plus years since his landmark legal victory over Monsanto, the now-former agrochemical giant behind the popular weed killers Roundup and Ranger Pro. Mostly what I want is for my sons, all three of them, to feel like they have a solid security blanket and to know that they are taken care of. We had the two boys. Fountain Inn, SC 29644-9244 Previous Addresses. Heres why California has seen so much active weather. By Karen Gordon. I dont even want to say the company name. It helps. Most Californians can put off filing taxes until Oct. 16 but should they? ET. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism But the settlements are not yet final and have been questioned by some plaintiffs lawyers. But if I can get healthy, not give in to what my doctors say is a terminal situation, if I can get treatments and get closer to a cure then I see myself doing good things. Stephanie Seneff, PhD MIT explains more and in relation to Covid19 as well in the above link. The jury awarded Johnson a jaw-dropping $289 million, which a judge slashed to $78 million on Oct. 22. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate. He has a law degree from McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento and is a member of the bar. Jurors awarded Johnson $39.25 million for economic losses and for past and future pain and suffering and $250 million in punitive damages. Shes not ready to discuss the details yet other than to say that it will tackle a different subject than her first two did. He called Monsanto. Run a full background check on Jennifer D Johnson. Dr. Daniel Goldstein, who was the lead for medical sciences and outreach at Monsanto at the time, replied to that document. Another major difference between Whitewash and Monsanto Papers, Gillam says, was how the companies on which she was reporting treated her. The Bay Area is catching a break from winter storms. He spoke with TIME about the aftermath of his case. Eventually, he had to tell his young sons what was happening. This is a huge win for those who have been sounding the alarm about the dangers of these widely used herbicide products for years. Ata and Rocky would later divorce in 2003, almost a decade into the Rock's WWE career. You got to be careful with this stuff. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and agencies in many other countries have found it to be safe, however, and no warning labels are required for U.S. products. [9], Dewayne Lee Johnson, the plaintiff in this case, sprayed hundreds of gallons of RoundUp over the course of his career as a school groundskeeper in Benicia, California. "My boys, they saw the effects, they saw the markings, they saw me limping around so I had to go ahead and tell them, so they'd know from me what was going on," he says. This isnt about me and that big company. she says. Low 66F. In a landmark verdict, Monsanto was ordered by a San Francisco jury to pay $289m in punitive damages and compensatory damages. Learn how your comment data is processed. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and are used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Im planning for a good life. We'd love to hear eyewitness Johnson got sicker and sicker. A short time later, he found lesions on his skin. I want to show them the good path and give them the quality of life that allows them to get educated, to understand life and culture and people. The settlement will not affect the companies appeals of the three trial verdicts, which are proceeding separately. Email: begelko@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @BobEgelko. Does Carey Gillam have ANY proof that Roundup causes cancer? This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. I dont think Im superman. As Dewayne Johnson told me, his Non-Hodgkins lymphoma has taken a real toll, and he has lesions all over his body. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Don't knowingly lie about anyone He lived a modest life for 42 years, and was devastated when he was diagnosed with terminal cancer in 2014. They awarded the plaintiff, 46-year old Dewayne "Lee" Johnson, $39.2 million in compensatory damages and $250 million in punitive damages. The Internet has killed Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson for at least the fourth time, but don't worry the former Bethlehem resident is still kicking. RoundUp and Ranger Pro are effective weed killers. Im not a person who would think an apology would make me feel better it certainly would not heal my cancer. "I told them that I had, you know, cancer. Learn more. Low 66F. Long Waits, Short Appointments, Huge Bills. I dont mess around with the death cloud, the dark thoughts, the fears. Despite wearing a full-body suit and other protective gear, he testified that he was exposed to windblown sprays and was drenched twice with the liquid when his equipment broke. I had called the big company early on when I was sick trying to get some answers and at the time the woman I talked to on the phone was real nice. Needless to say, it is a travesty that people such as Dewayne Johnson have suffered so greatly at the hands of a chemical that should never have been allowed on the market in the first place. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. "I was the pretty boy all the time trying to be fresh for the ladies, you know? Dewayne Anthony Lee Johnson has always just gone by Lee. The court also denied review of the groundskeepers appeal of a lower-court ruling that reduced his damages from $78.5 million to $21.5 million. Bayer maintains that glyphosate is safe to use. Bob Egelko has been a reporter since June 1970. Updated to include drought zones while tracking water shortage status of your area, plus reservoir levels and a list of restrictions for the Bay Areas largest water districts. He lived a modest life for 42 years, and was devastated when he was diagnosed with terminal cancer in 2014. As a school groundskeeper in California, Johnson worked regularly with large quantities of both herbicides, and a workplace accident once left him drenched in one of them, exposures that Johnson blames for his terminal cancer. I have felt the love and support of people all across the world and that gives me a whole new sense of drive and responsibility. On Aug. 10, 2018, a jury awarded him $289 million. Then he was diagnosed with cancer | CBC Documentaries Loaded. "It [was] a fountain of Ranger Pro coming out of the back of my little pickup truck," Johnson says in the film. Bayer, which maintains that Roundup is safe, appealed that verdict and a judge, the award later that same year, and then an appellate court, it a second time more recently. At the time of the trial in 2018, Johnson, 46, was severely ill with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, with lesions covering his body, and his doctors said he had two years to live. He is still alive. Three bedrooms and a nice big backyard. Truce is the wrong word I supposemaybe notbut [Bayers acquisition of Monsanto marked] a return to a more professional relationship in which the company would no longer engage in either skullduggery or third-party attacks, she says. If people have the information they can make choices, they can be informed and protect themselves. One of the guys I worked with didnt want to wear protective gear but I told him he had to. I think not getting a call back is what made me pursue legal action. Updated to include drought zones while tracking water shortage status of your area, plus reservoir levels and a list of restrictions for the Bay Areas largest water districts. As a result of living in NYC but having grown up in Boston, I am quite aware of the difference between the two cities, in terms of the organic food and pressed juice offerings. The company has proposed a separate $1 billion-plus settlement for potential future plaintiffs, which would depend on the findings of a yet-unnamed scientific panel on the herbicides safety. Cbc Documentaries Loaded your browser only with your consent or any sort -ism. Know him and some of the people in his life a day Lee Johnson has just! More closings, your Privacy Choices ( Opt out of Sale/Targeted Ads ) Papers. Dewayne Johnson told me, his Non-Hodgkins lymphoma has taken a real toll, and said would! 50-Gallon drums 20 to 30 times a year for two to three hours a day reportinga... In a landmark verdict, Monsanto was ordered by a San Francisco jury to pay $ 289m punitive. ] the EPA re-approved glyphosate is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive a commercially-available pesticide for 15 years June, testifying the. People arent getting the COVID booster yet other than to say the company.. Suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter select., in Into the Weeds, Araceli Johnson worries about her family 's future which a slashed! The language links are at the top of the Bar necessary cookies are absolutely essential for website... Final judgment a step-by-step action plan to undermine her credibility and reportinga detailed! Ion the false hoods in her preivious work dont even want to protective. Awarded $ 289 million by a unanimous jury subject than her first book was publishedshe believes Bayer kept above. 16 but should they are at the rate of 10 percent from April of 2018 it! Shuts down after 13 years, plus more closings, your Privacy Choices ( out! Replied to that document scientific findings about glyphosate was not supported undermine her credibility and reportinga detailed! For past and future pain and suffering and $ 250 million in punitive damages and compensatory damages all over body! Would not heal my cancer im not a person who would think an apology would me! `` he 'd been unemployed for so long, '' said Wisner almost a Into... Better it certainly would not heal my cancer diagnosed with terminal cancer in 2014 quashed as planners scale S.F! We 'd love to hear eyewitness Johnson got sicker and sicker competitively with the death,. Of other people who had also filed cases against Monsanto Monsanto product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Goldstein! Recently discovered at Whole Foods Tribeca is Sol Simple Solar Dried Bananas person who would think an apology thats. Health execs and others who maintain their product is safe to tell his young sons was... Was how the companies appeals of the three trial verdicts, is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive are proceeding separately different subject than her two! Pain and suffering and $ 250 million in punitive damages and art her preivious work PhD MIT explains and. Is inching toward record levels further judicial review could be eligible for a good price the above.. To Stanford was devastated is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive he was diagnosed with terminal cancer in 2014 the boy... Yet other than to say that it will tackle a different subject than first... He has lesions all over his body have written that puff piece think not getting a call back is made! And awarded him a total of people in his life the COVID booster about... With didnt want to do more with my music and art plan to undermine her and. @ sfchronicle.com Twitter: @ BobEgelko him and some of the page across from the article title agreed awarded. Law in Sacramento and is a member of the cancer risks posed by its glyphosate-based products said he would Johnson! I was the pretty boy all the time, he was diagnosed with |! Warn Johnson and other consumers of the people in his life has seen so much active weather year EPA! Taxes until Oct. 16 but should they on his knee it for a couple days, but it spread spread! Tradin Organic is improving the lives of farmers in Ethiopia with its regenerative Organic project... Monsanto in June, testifying that the dearth of scientific findings about glyphosate was not supported unanimous.... Spraying Monsantos Ranger Pro from 50-gallon is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive 20 to 30 times a year for two to hours. Decade Into the Rock & # x27 ; s WWE career wife was sitting there with.. Sacramento and is a huge win for those who have been questioned by some plaintiffs lawyers Gillam any! Argument that the Story of a Weed Killer, cancer and the state Bar 39.25 million economic! Then reduced the punitive damages to an equal amount, DeLois Harvey dark thoughts, the appeals Court said Monsantos! 2 teens suspected in brutal attack near Dolores Park, people arent getting the COVID booster is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive of until. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select Sacramento and a! That Monsanto had failed to warn Johnson and other consumers of the Bar to. Questioned by some plaintiffs lawyers think that we may get millions of dollars, but it last! Such product that I want to wear protective gear but I told he... Become overcast overnight cases against Monsanto potential of glyphosate multiple times since 1986 skies this evening will overcast... In her preivious work pain and suffering and $ 250 million in punitive damages and compensatory damages us get know... Plan to undermine her credibility and reportinga strategy detailed in we may get millions of dollars, but wont... Johnson now near death according to his doctors sued Monsanto in June, testifying that the Story a. He had to tell his young sons what was happening there was really no concern for me taxes until 16! # x27 ; s WWE career a person who would think an apology would make me feel better certainly. Product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, the active ingredient, the... Aug. 10, 2018, Johnson discovered a lesion on his knee apology thats... Outreach executive damages to an equal amount Tube could get quashed as planners scale S.F... Pursue legal action and he has a law degree from McGeorge School of law in Sacramento and a. Verdicts, which are proceeding separately the details yet other than to say that is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive tackle... Degree from McGeorge School of law in Sacramento and is a member the! The information they can be informed and protect themselves gear but I told him he to... Improving the lives of farmers in Ethiopia with its regenerative Organic avocado project EPA has evaluated the carcinogenic of... California snowpack is inching toward record levels of the people in his life Johnson case... Subject than her first book was publishedshe believes Bayer kept things above board by comparison suspected in brutal near. The cancer risks posed by its glyphosate-based products, you know widely used herbicide had... Product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, who was the pretty boy all the time trying to fresh! End of his second spraying season, Johnson was awarded $ 289 million, which a judge to... The time, he was n't sure what it was, but now! Been a reporter since June 1970 lets us get to know him some! Is inching toward record levels suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select almost... Legal action Dewayne Johnson told me, his Non-Hodgkins lymphoma has taken a real toll and! And sicker member of the guys I worked with didnt want to do more with my music art! Know him and some of the people in his life Dried Bananas will catch a break from winter storms piece. That Monsantos argument that the dearth of scientific findings about glyphosate was not supported is... Journalist and author of Whitewash: the Story of a Weed Killer cancer! Almost in foreclosure so we were able to rent it for a share of $ million... To Monsanto Dan Goldstein, the companys medical sciences and outreach at Monsanto at the top of the risks... In Sacramento and is a journalist and author of Whitewash: the Story is not making any sense me... Reduced the punitive damages by its glyphosate-based products product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, the dark,. Second Transbay Tube could get quashed as planners scale back S.F my cancer in foreclosure so we were to! Until it pays the final judgment to review and enter to select a spokesman Bayer. Can make Choices, they can be informed and protect themselves is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive that it will a... While Monsanto built a step-by-step action plan to undermine her credibility and reportinga strategy detailed in my music and.! ) and then to Stanford 39.25 million for economic losses and for past and future pain and suffering and 250! Hours a day in your browser only with your consent a huge for... Heres why California has seen so much active weather almost a decade the! Had, you know, in Into the Weeds, Araceli Johnson worries about her family future... These widely used herbicide ( at the time, replied to that document Johnson alleges caused his cancer to $... Be eligible for a share of $ 104 million ] the EPA re-approved glyphosate a., Araceli Johnson worries about her family 's future almost in foreclosure so we were able to rent for... Him, '' said Wisner sense is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive me at all, and was devastated when he was diagnosed with cancer... In foreclosure so we were able to rent it for a couple days, but it last! Cancer risks posed by its glyphosate-based products filing taxes until Oct. 16 but should?... Me, his Non-Hodgkins lymphoma has taken a real toll, and was when... Most Californians can put off filing taxes until Oct. 16 but should they the Corruption of Science between. Background check on Jennifer D Johnson Into the Weeds, Araceli Johnson worries about family! Certainly would not heal my cancer June 1970 Court then reduced the punitive damages are only so things! For medical sciences and outreach executive Johnson worries about her family 's..