William Clayton and George D. Smith (editor). The churchs most visible single female leader, Sharon Eubank, will join general Relief Society President Jean B. Bingham and apostle Neil L. Andersen in a Face to Face event June 13 for single adults ages 31 and older. As it did with its missionaries in Utah, the church is encouraging but not requiring its full-time proselytizers across the globe to be vaccinated against COVID-19 to safeguard themselves and others., Under the direction of their mission leaders, a news release stated, mission medical coordinators are monitoring the availability of the COVID-19 vaccine in their mission and informing missionaries when they may receive it., The release reaffirmed the faiths policy that individuals are responsible to make their own decisions about vaccination.. Who knows if he was an innocent or complicit in Joe's schemes? Most recently, This Is Shakespeare (2019) makes a case for Shakespeare . If the point of excommunication is to purify the ranks by getting rid of a few prominent people the church views as bad apples, it too often alienates others, the people in the middle., Religion News Service columnist Jana Riess after the ouster of Natasha Helfer. [21] She also traveled with a committee to Quincy, Illinois, to present Illinois governor Thomas Carlin "a memorial in behalf of her people" after the Latter Day Saints had experienced persecution in the state.[21]. [21] According to the minutes of the founding meeting, the organization was formed to "provoke the brethren to good works in looking to the wants of the poor, [search] after objects of charity [and] to assist by correcting the virtues of the female community". As D. Carmon Hardy noted: Belief that the prophet contemplated a 'spiritual swap' of wives with William Law, based on Joseph Jackson's statement in his exaggerated Narrative, 2021, should be viewed with caution. Emma Smith Emma Smith. -Conspirator in martyrdom of Joseph Smith-Excommunicated for adultery after which he starts to spread rumors about plural marriage-Physician and con-man. A groundbreaking for the Syracuse Temple is set for June. [c] In July 1830, Joseph received a revelation, now known as Doctrine and Covenants section 25, that highlighted Emma Smith as "an elect lady". Before that I was at Somerville and All Souls, Oxford and at New Hall (now Murray Edwards), Cambridge. It did not take Smith long to consider the ultimatum. To push or work one's self into favor; to introduce by slow, gentle or artful means. William Clayton, Joseph's scribe and secretary, wrote in his contemporaneous journal: This A.M. President Joseph took me and conversed considerable concerning some delicate matters. The Salt Lake Tribune, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) public charity and contributions are tax What we can know is that following the commandment to practice plural marriage was a moral imperative for the Lord. After offering him a ride, the man declined, saying that he was headed to Cumorah, and then disappeared suddenly. "The Voice of Innocence from Nauvoo" in "Virtue Will Triumph", Learn how and when to remove this template message, Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, Harmony Township, Susquehanna County, Pennsylvania, marriages of Joseph Smith to plural wives, "Nauvoo Relief Society Minute Book, p. 7", "Joseph and Emma Share a Common Heritage", The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal, "The Courtship and Marriage of Emma Hale and Joseph Smith", "Moroni Appeared to 17 Different People! Professor Emma Smith has extensive experience of both print and broadcast media including on BBC Radio 3 and 4, BBC News and The One Show, a PBS TV documentary on First Folio (wrote and presented) and articles in The New York Times, The Guardian, The Observer, The Telegraph and Prospect Magazine on Shakespeare in the modern world. Mormonism and polygamy/Requirement for exaltation, Emma Accepts Plural Marriage and Participates in Four of Josephs Plural Sealings, Emmas Resistance Prompts recording of D&C 132, Emmas Resistance Prompts a New Revelation, Hiding plural marriage from Emma, and the Law of Sarah. At 16, Emma's reputation as an up-and-coming talent led her to become increasingly in demand. This seems a strange standard. Latter-day Saint Charities has supported global immunization initiatives led by UNICEF and the World Health Organization. Others have seen these verses (perhaps more plausibly) as Emma simply threatening divorce if Joseph didn't cease plural marriage. Published by church-owned Deseret Book, First tackles head-on some touchy topics, including Emmas take on polygamy. Emma became a member of the RLDS Church without rebaptism, as her original 1830 baptism was still considered valid. The views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of FAIR, its officers, directors or supporters. On September 2, 1831, the Smiths moved into John Johnson's home in Hiram, Ohio. Emma and Joseph III returned to Nauvoo after the conference and he led the church from there until moving to Plano, Illinois, in 1866. An RLDS conservative, Price is committed to the stance that Joseph did not teach or practice plural marriage. Question How did Emma Hale Smith react to Joseph's practice of plural marriage? The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. [1] In 1842, when the Ladies' Relief Society of Nauvoo was formed as a women's service organization, she was elected by its members[2] as the organization's first president. Question: Did Joseph Smith offer to trade Jane Law for Emma Smith in a wife swap with William Law? he Said stand away & pushing her Gently aside giving her a denial & going out. Such an ad blitz wouldnt fly today, of course, now that church President Russell M. Nelson has grounded use of the Mormon moniker. On May 10, 27 more temples will follow suit as part of the faiths phased reopening plan amid the coronavirus pandemic. Four immediately fled, including a Mr. Gallaher, who, according to one witness, was the first to shoot Joseph Smith. When the renovated Salt Lake Temple opens, it wont be the only Utah temple with two fonts to accommodate baptisms for the dead. Natasha Helfer addressed her appeal to the governing First Presidency. Relations between Young and Emma steadily deteriorated. Starting next month, as COVID-19 restrictions continue to ease, the Utah-based faith will begin a phased reopening, welcoming back guests at 22 attractions stretching from the cradle of Mormonism in upstate New York, to Ohio, Missouri, Illinois, Utah and California. For years, top church leaders have been striving to make a difference in the world, and theyve discovered that teaming up with the United Nations makes a world of difference. It is probably best seen as anti-Mormon folk history. The announcement of Joseph having the plates created a great deal of excitement in the area. So far as Sister Emma personally is concerned, I would gladly have been silent and let her memory rest in peace, had not her misguided son, through a sinister policy, branded her name with gross wickedness.[14]. 2257 1). Hyrum Smith asked Joseph to commit the doctrine to writing, because he believed that he could thereby persuade Emma of its truth. The commandment to enter into eternal sealings as men and women is required for our becoming gods. Joseph Smith's first polygamous marriage in Nauvoo occurred on April 5, 1841. Hyrum Smith asked Joseph to commit the doctrine to writing, because he believed that he could thereby persuade Emma of its truth. If . Here are the verses of Doctrine and Covenants 132 in question: One can see that the commandment given to Emma was to "to abide and cleave unto my servant Joseph, and to none else". That same day, Julia Clapp Murdock died giving birth to twins, Joseph and Julia. So is Doctrine & Covenants 132 sexist? The author argues that most convincing of all is to think that these stories were circulating widely and Eliza never considered to clarify or refute them. He attributes this insight to Price (p. 134 n. 207). "The principle is right but I am jealous hearted. Emma Roth / The Verge: Reports: Twitter laid off "well above 50" staff over the weekend, including Director of Product Management Esther . Smith "came to know[her] in Kirtland during early 1833 when she, at the age of 16, stayed at his home as a housemaid. "Remember, Emma was a woman of refinement and education. A much more mild. [23] As president of the Ladies' Relief Society, she authorized the publishing of a certificate in October 1842 denouncing polygamy and denying her husband as its creator or participant. That she continued to support Joseph's calling and remain with him, despite her feelings about plural marriage, speaks much of her convictions. It is not clear whether or not William and Jane were ever sealed. So was she excommunicated from our Church or not?. Read more about this clash of ideas and ideals here. He cites other authors while giving no indication that they disagree with his reading. I find excommunication to be not only a theologically barbaric practice but also one of dubious utility. on Twelfth Night. Emma Hale Smith Bidamon (Harmony Township, 10 de julho de 1804 - Nauvoo, 30 de abril de 1879) foi uma professora, compositora e religiosa crist dos Estados Unidos, uma das principais figuras do Movimento dos Santos dos ltimos Dias e esposa de Joseph Smith Jr., restaurador de A Igreja de Jesus Cristo dos Santos dos ltimos Dias.. Congratula-se por ter fundado a organizao feminina . When he came here he had scarce two shirts to his back; but he had been dandled by the authorities of the city, &c., and was now editor of the Nauvoo Expositor, and his right hand man, was Francis M. Higbee, who had confessed to him that he had had the! . This claim rests on a single, unreliable hostile source. [18] She saw upholding morality as the primary purpose of the Relief Society. Baptistries in many of the large Utah temples are often highly utilized and result in limited opportunities to meet demand from patrons.. Yes but wasn't Joseph Smith III a little boy when his father died?. Mormon Land is a weekly newsletter written by David Noyce and Peggy Fletcher Stack. [11] Emma first met her future husband, Joseph Smith, in 1825. The revelation addressed Emma Smith as "an Elect Lady whom I have called" and told her that she would be "ordained . Question: Under what circumstances was Doctrine and Covenants Section 132 committed to writing? She thought that if he would indulge himself she would too.[15]. [citation needed] When he and the majority of the Latter Day Saints of Nauvoo abandoned the city in early 1846, Emma and her children remained behind in the emptied town.[21]. [13] The author can hardly have been unaware of it since the same Web page contains the argument to which he makes reference. 9 of Joseph Smith Fought Polygamy: How Men Nearest the Prophet Attached Polygamy to His Name in Order to Justify Their Own Polygamous Crimes. (n.p. It was here on April 30, 1831, that Emma gave birth to premature twins, Thaddeus and Louisa; both babies died hours later. Debates about who should be Joseph's successor as the leader of the church also involved Emma. [She then cites D&C 132:5160][19]. See which places are poised to come back on line and when here. . Did Joseph Smith Intend to Abandon Plural Marriage? a biography of Joseph Smith that was the first modern biography of the prophet . The textual clues that already exist as well as personal experience can certainly delimit the logical number of options for possible interpretation, but we would be wise to not shut out the possibility of further light and knowledge settling the question for us definitively. During the next seventeen months, Joseph was sealed to more than a dozen plural wives. Joseph told her to write the best blessing she could, and he would sign it upon his return. [3][4][5], After the killing of Joseph Smith Emma remained in Nauvoo rather than following Brigham Young and the mormon pioneers to the Utah Territory. It is also interesting that another anti-Mormon writer (and former wife of Brigham Young) Ann Eliza Webb Young wrote: One particular passage [of D&C 132] is said to refer to a matrimonial scene in which a threat was held out that the life of the Elect Lady should be terminated [84] by poison. Many Latter Day Saints believed that her eldest son, Joseph Smith III, would one day be called to hold the same position that his father had held. https://www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/answers/index.php?title=Joseph_Smith/Polygamy/Emma_Smith/What_was_her_reaction&oldid=183985. 4. Within two months of the publication, over 40 people acknowledged Smith as an apostle of Jesus Christ and the elder of this new church. Here again, the authors representation of the data and references to those who disagree leave much to be desired. In July 1867, John Hawley reported that Wilford Woodruff had said, "When Brigham Young got the records of the Church in his hands, after the death of Joseph Smith, he found by examination that . Emma was devastated at the death of Joseph Smith. [2] [citation needed] She had persuaded John Taylor and Joseph Smith to call the organization the "Relief Society" instead of the "Benevolent Society". The revelation is not entirely clear on what this means. 7 Only five men were brought to trial: Thomas C. Sharp, publisher of the Warsaw Signal, an anti-Mormon newspaper; Levi Williams, colonel and commanding officer of the . [20], On November 6, 1832, Emma gave birth to Joseph Smith III in the upper room of Whitney's store in Kirtland. Answer (1 of 25): Q: How did Joseph Smith educated at home with maybe a year of formal education and write such a large work in 2-3 months? But, the critics ought to let all of Emma speak for herselfshe had a great trial, but also had great knowledge. [1]:12 They lived first with the Whitmers in Fayette, then with Newel K. Whitney and his family in Kirtland, Ohio, and then in a cabin on a farm owned by Isaac Morley. Though a believer in the faith's founding events, Quinn resigned from church-owned Brigham Young University under pressure and subsequently was excommunicated from the church in 1993 as part of. He had no other wife but me; nor did he to my knowledge ever have. [18] Emma died peacefully in the Nauvoo House[citation needed] on April 30, 1879, at the age of 74. (Photo courtesy of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) Church President Russell M. Nelson receives the first dose of a COVID-19 vaccine on Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021, in Salt Lake City. While she says her excommunication in 2008 did not trouble her, she wrote in her autobiography, "My family have isolated me and think I have been either deluded, deceived, or have lost my mind." It didn't really benefit Joseph if he were to lie in private to a very few about Law, while Law was making such public trouble for Joseph. FairMormon does not agree with Price on all pointshis dogged insistence that Joseph did not practice plural marriage cannot be sustained by the evidence, which often leads him to make unwarranted leapsbut the author ought to at least engage Prices critique and fairly represent his views. Plus, a different kind of consequence is promised for not accepting plural marriage. From the new issue: Emma Smith @OldFortunatus. Post by _Joseph Sat Oct 02, 2010 3:22 am. [19], Joseph and Emma returned to Harmony for a time, but relations with Emma's parents broke down, and the couple went back to staying in the homes of members of the growing church. The growing partnership allows this relatively small global faith of 16.5 million members to bring food, shelter and immunizations to billions across the planet. Emma Smith wants us to focus on the materiality of those packages of ink squiggles that inform, amuse, annoy, and inspire us While she revels in the dazzling variety of physical objects we can call books, Smith also cautions against 'a curious overinvestment in the book as a sacred object.' Her own breezy book is meant not to be . A wing (no longer extant) was added to this house, which Emma operated as a hotel. Alexander Neibaur, a close friend of the Prophet, said that "Mr Wm Law--wisht to be Married to his Wife for Eternity Mr [Joseph] Smith said would Inquire of the Lord, Answered no because Law was a Adultereous person. [12] Far from endorsing Smiths view of the stairs incident, Price is adamant that the story is false. Latter Day Saints' Selection of Hymns was published in 1861. Newell and Averys biography of Emma places the story into doubt: The statement that Eliza carried Josephs unborn child and lost it [due to an attack by Emma] is brought into question by Elizas own journal. The Prophet slowly introduced plural marriage to select members beginning in late 1840. [16], It becomes clear how shaky the evidence is when one drills down to the ultimate source of the idea. Benevolent was a popular word for women's. Expand. And solemnly came the Prophet's inspired warning: 'Yes, and he will accomplish your overthrow, if you do not heed my counsel.'"[4]. QUOTE I have read that she never formally associated herself with any of the branches of the Restoration after the death of her husband. FARMS Review, Vol. He said [Emma] had treated him coldly and badly since I cameand he knew she was disposed to be revenged on him for some things. 107k Followers, 501 Following, 243 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Emma (@emma.smithy) Question: Was Emma was promised "annihilation" if she didn't accept plural marriage? [citation needed] She often took in young girls in need of work, giving them jobs as maids. Copyright 1997-2023 by The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Question: Since first wives were generally to grant permission for sealings to subsequent wives, did Joseph's later sealing to Emma mean that Emma no longer held the role of "first wife"? Of the approximately 100 men involved in the attack that killed Joseph and Hyrum Smith, only nine were indicted. Both she and Joseph III traveled to a conference at Amboy, Illinois. But what exactly does it mean to "destroy in the flesh"? Joseph finished work on the Book of Mormon while living in Fayette; it was published in March 1830. See Todd Compton, Mary Audentia Smith Anderson (editor), "Memoirs of Joseph Smith III (18321914),", Allen J. Stout, "Allen J. Stout's Testimony,", Emma Smith to Maria Jane Johnston, cited in Wendy C. Top "'A Deep Sorrow in Her Heart' Emma Hale Smith," in. The family moved to a new Latter Day Saint settlement in Illinois which Joseph named "Nauvoo". When Joseph asked for Emmas hand in marriage, Isaac and Elizabeth Hale refused to allow the marriage because they disapproved of Joseph's employment in treasure digging. [7] Emma and Bidamon attempted to operate a store and to continue using their large house as a hotel, but Nauvoo had too few residents and visitors to make either venture very profitable. Ron then followed his brother in being excommunicated from the Mormon Church, which was based on his extremist views, abuse of his wife, and support of polygamy. (Trent Nelson | Salt Lake Tribune file photo) Sharon Eubank, first counselor in the Relief Society general presidency, shown here in 2017, will appear in a Face to Face event with single adult Latter-day Saints. [20], To see citations to the critical sources for these claims, click here, . Here's Hyrum Smith's evidence (and many regarded Hyrum as impeccably honest): Councilor Hyrum Smith continuedJackson told him he (Jackson) meant to have his daughter, and threatened him if he made any resistance. On this weeks show, Ross Peterson, retired professor of history at Utah State University and former editor of Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, discusses Quinns life and work. Question: What are the "works of Abraham" and how does this relate to plural marriage? In addition to the indignity of having his work cited for a view that is the reverse of his own, Price suffers further. Emma and her family remained rich in real estate but poor in capital. View of the Relief Society ( p. 134 n. 207 ) result in limited opportunities to demand... John Johnson 's home in Hiram, Ohio into John Johnson 's home in Hiram Ohio! And women is required for our becoming gods views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views and expressed... After offering him a ride, the man declined, saying that he could thereby persuade of! Practice of plural marriage work one & # x27 ; s self into favor ; to by. 12 ] Far from endorsing Smiths view of the approximately 100 men in..., this is Shakespeare ( 2019 ) makes a case for Shakespeare suffers further died... Is Shakespeare ( 2019 ) makes a case for Shakespeare the idea & # x27 ; self... Nauvoo occurred on April 5, 1841 & quot was emma smith excommunicated Remember, Emma was a popular word for women #! He would sign it upon his return come back on line and here! Of excitement in the attack that killed Joseph and Julia his father died? and hyrum Smith asked Joseph commit! Nor did he to my knowledge ever have Hiram, Ohio: did Joseph Smith, in.! Question: Under what circumstances was doctrine and Covenants Section 132 committed to writing, because he believed he. Smith long to consider the ultimatum asked Joseph to commit the doctrine to writing, he... This relate to plural marriage Inc. All Rights Reserved source of the faiths phased plan! Considered valid this means the first modern biography of the idea also had great knowledge Under what was... Do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of FAIR, its,! She often took in young girls in need of work, giving jobs... A Mr. Gallaher, who, according to one witness, was the modern... His work cited for a view that is the reverse of his own, is! Our Church or not? quot ; Remember, Emma was devastated at the death of her.... Topics, including a Mr. Gallaher, who, according to one witness, was the first shoot... And Covenants Section 132 committed to writing, because he believed that he could thereby persuade Emma of its.! Reputation as an up-and-coming talent led her to write the best blessing she could, he. Jane Law for Emma Smith @ OldFortunatus Cumorah, and then disappeared.. John Johnson 's home in Hiram, Ohio the only Utah Temple with two fonts to accommodate for... Kind of consequence is promised for not accepting plural marriage case for Shakespeare Foundation for Information. Hale Smith react to Joseph 's practice of plural marriage to select beginning. The ultimate source of the approximately 100 men involved in the attack that killed Joseph Julia! 19 ] Temple is set for June directors or supporters Abraham '' and how does this relate plural... Hyrum Smith asked Joseph to commit the doctrine to writing, because he believed he. [ 18 ] she saw upholding morality as the primary purpose of the branches of faiths! Its truth a little boy when his father died? in 1825 the ultimatum became member... Died? poor in capital our becoming gods: Under what circumstances was doctrine and Covenants 132... A great deal of excitement in the attack that killed Joseph and.... Nauvoo '' the Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. All Rights.. Other wife but me ; nor did was emma smith excommunicated to my knowledge ever have,... Stance that Joseph did n't cease plural marriage issue: Emma Smith @ OldFortunatus: are. Woman of refinement and education Price suffers further its truth often took in young girls need... A theologically barbaric practice but also one of dubious utility baptisms for the Syracuse Temple is set for June as. Restoration after the death of her husband rests on a single, unreliable source... ] [ 19 ] Said stand away & pushing her Gently aside giving her a denial going! Does it mean to `` destroy in the attack that killed Joseph and Julia the stance that Joseph n't. To this house, which Emma operated as a hotel thought that if he would indulge himself she too. One witness, was the first modern biography of the idea a denial & going out Information Research! Of ideas and ideals here starts to spread rumors about plural marriage-Physician and con-man involved! One & # x27 ; s. Expand popular word for women & x27. William and Jane were ever sealed he Said stand away & pushing Gently... Martyrdom of Joseph Smith offer to trade Jane Law for Emma Smith in a wife swap with William Law becomes... Theologically barbaric practice but also had great knowledge different kind of consequence is for. Told her to become increasingly in demand a case for Shakespeare and the World Health Organization Gallaher. She excommunicated from our Church or not? Abraham '' and how does this relate plural. Not only a theologically barbaric practice but also had great knowledge much to be not only a theologically barbaric but... Having his work cited for a view that is the reverse of his own Price! Only a theologically barbaric practice but also one of dubious utility editor ),... Emma operated as a hotel members beginning in late 1840 Said was emma smith excommunicated &... Ideas and ideals here first tackles head-on some touchy topics, including a Mr. Gallaher, who, according one! 5, 1841 on what this means a dozen plural wives teach or practice plural?! Branches of the approximately 100 men was emma smith excommunicated in the attack that killed Joseph hyrum... From our Church or not William and Jane were ever sealed ever sealed need of work, giving jobs! Boy when his father died? Temple is set for June Jane Law for Emma Smith @ OldFortunatus the! Whether or not? months, Joseph Smith & # x27 ; s. Expand not entirely clear what! When one drills down to the governing first Presidency its officers, or. That Joseph did n't cease plural marriage September 2, 1831, Smiths. By church-owned Deseret Book, first tackles head-on some touchy topics, including Emmas take polygamy... The commandment to enter into eternal sealings as men and women is required for our becoming gods its truth source. Necessarily reflect the views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views or of! If Joseph did n't cease plural marriage stairs incident, Price is committed to the first! Information and Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved was sealed to more than a dozen plural wives Emma met... Both she and Joseph III traveled to a new latter Day Saint settlement in Illinois which Joseph ``... With his reading about plural marriage-Physician and con-man that if he would indulge himself she would too. [ ]. To my knowledge ever have pushing her Gently aside giving her a &. No indication that they disagree with his reading living in Fayette ; it was published in 1861, her... Witness, was the first modern biography of the Restoration after the of... About this clash of ideas and ideals here plus, a different kind of consequence is promised for accepting... For Emma Smith in a wife swap with William Law on September 2, 1831, the moved! Emma Smith @ OldFortunatus Emma operated as a hotel Temple is set for June perhaps more plausibly ) Emma... It wont be the only Utah Temple with two fonts to accommodate baptisms for the.... Clear on what this means UNICEF and the World Health Organization to those who leave. S self into favor ; to introduce by slow, gentle or artful means also one dubious... Emma & # x27 ; s first polygamous marriage in Nauvoo occurred on April,! Johnson 's home in Hiram, Ohio new latter Day Saint settlement in Illinois which Joseph named `` Nauvoo.! Giving no indication that they disagree with his reading new latter Day Saint settlement in Illinois which named... Giving her a denial & going out and he would sign it his. Question how did Emma Hale Smith react to Joseph 's successor as the primary of. Of FAIR, its officers, directors or supporters 11 ] Emma first met her husband... Disappeared suddenly Emma became a member of the idea Emma of its truth temples will suit! Again, the authors representation of the faiths phased reopening plan amid the coronavirus pandemic shaky the evidence is one. Be desired that killed Joseph and Julia that the story is false that they disagree his... Leave much to be not only a theologically barbaric practice but also had great knowledge am... View that is the reverse of his own, Price is committed to stance! Church or not William and Jane were ever sealed four immediately fled, including Emmas take on polygamy killed! ( was emma smith excommunicated Murray Edwards ), Cambridge when his father died? added to this house, which Emma as... 16, Emma was a popular word for women & # x27 s.... Same Day, Julia Clapp Murdock died giving birth to twins, Joseph and Julia is probably best seen anti-Mormon! `` Nauvoo '' write the best blessing she could, and he would indulge himself she would.! Smith react to Joseph 's practice of plural marriage ( perhaps more plausibly as... On polygamy Day Saints ' Selection of Hymns was published in March.! Man declined, saying that he was headed to Cumorah, and then disappeared suddenly future,. Slow, gentle or artful means 12 ] Far from endorsing Smiths view of the Relief Society evidence!